Publication - Impact assessment
Environmental Protection (Single-use Plastic Products) (Scotland) Regulations 2021: business and regulatory impact assessment - final
Final Business and Regulatory Impact Assessment (BRIA) for the introduction of market restrictions on problematic single-use plastic items as identified in Article 5 of the EU Single-Use Plastics Directive (EU SUPD).
17.0 Annex C: Full NPV tables by individual item
1. Cutlery
| Stakeholder | Impact | NPV under Baseline (£) | NPV under Option 1 (£) | Net change to NPV (£) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Society | Carbon impacts (production) | -445,384 | -231,052 | 214,331 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (recycling) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (composting) | 16,607 | 20,701 | 4,095 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (incineration) | -98,768 | 27,385 | -126,153 |
| Society | Carbon Impacts (Landfill) | -7,030 | -14,728 | -7,698 |
| Local Authorities | Recycled material | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Local Authorities | Composting costs | -77,652 | -98,412 | -20,759 |
| Local Authorities | Energy from Waste costs | -490,166 | -457,416 | 32,750 |
| Local Authorities | Landfill costs | -21,072 | -18,246 | 2,826 |
| Local Authorities | Direct littering costs | -220,941 | -216,690 | 4,250 |
| Society | Indirect littering costs | -12,111,272 | -11,435,373 | 675,899 |
| Local Authorities | Residual waste | -368,507 | -362,225 | 6,282 |
| Society | Change in item costs | -98,013,011 | -92,765,941 | 5,247,069 |
| Total | -111,837,195 | -105,551,998 | 6,285,198 |
2. Plates
| Stakeholder | Impact | NPV under Baseline (£) | NPV under Option 1 (£) | Net change to NPV (£) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Society | Carbon impacts (production) | -765,250 | -654,055 | 111,195 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (recycling) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (composting) | 36,844 | 38,618 | -1,774 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (incineration) | -16,787 | 57,184 | -73,971 |
| Society | Carbon Impacts (Landfill) | -24,768 | -28,076 | -3,308 |
| Local Authorities | Recycled material | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Local Authorities | Composting costs | -100,249 | -105,216 | -4,966 |
| Local Authorities | Energy from Waste costs | -1,040,984 | -1,022,876 | -18,108 |
| Local Authorities | Landfill costs | -45,153 | -46,522 | -1,369 |
| Local Authorities | Direct littering costs | -220,859 | -220,311 | 548 |
| Society | Indirect littering costs | -1,965,927 | -1,860,489 | 105,438 |
| Local Authorities | Residual waste | -747,324 | -745,515 | 1,809 |
| Society | Change in item costs | -54,615,261 | -52,484,477 | 2,130,784 |
| Total | -59,505,718 | -57,071,734 | 2,433,984 |
3. Stirrers
| Stakeholder | Impact | NPV under Baseline (£) | NPV under Option 1 (£) | Net change to NPV (£) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Society | Carbon impacts (production) | -9,935 | -8,801 | 1,134 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (recycling) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (composting) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (incineration) | 1,856 | 2,427 | 571 |
| Society | Carbon Impacts (Landfill) | -767 | -870 | -104 |
| Local Authorities | Recycled material | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Local Authorities | Composting costs | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Local Authorities | Energy from Waste costs | -25,217 | -24,945 | 272 |
| Local Authorities | Landfill costs | -749 | -802 | -53 |
| Local Authorities | Direct littering costs | -928 | -928 | 0 |
| Society | Indirect littering costs | -83,774 | -79,233 | 4,541 |
| Local Authorities | Residual waste | -15,684 | -15,684 | 0 |
| Society | Change in item costs | -1,700,486 | -1,609,517 | 90,970 |
| Total | -1,835,685 | -1,738,353 | 97,332 |
4. Straws
| Stakeholder | Impact | NPV under Baseline (£) | NPV under Option 1 (£) | Net change to NPV (£) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Society | Carbon impacts (production) | -166,332 | -130,183 | 36,149 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (recycling) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (composting) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (incineration) | -22,319 | 9,137 | 31,456 |
| Society | Carbon Impacts (Landfill) | -1,675 | -3,966 | -2,291 |
| Local Authorities | Recycled material | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Local Authorities | Composting costs | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Local Authorities | Energy from Waste costs | -201,149 | -218,022 | -16,872 |
| Local Authorities | Landfill costs | -5,308 | -6,794 | -1,486 |
| Local Authorities | Direct littering costs | -73,769 | -81,529 | -7,760 |
| Society | Indirect littering costs | -13,397,519 | -12,645,234 | 752,285 |
| Local Authorities | Residual waste | -123,249 | -136,478 | -13,229 |
| Society | Change in item costs | -27,120,992 | -25,670,121 | 1,450,870 |
| Total | -41,112,312 | -38,883,191 | 2,229,121 |
5. Balloon sticks
| Stakeholder | Impact | NPV under Baseline (£) | NPV under Option 1 (£) | Net change to NPV (£) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Society | Carbon impacts (production) | -7,562 | -5,510 | 2,052 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (recycling) | 237 | 305 | 69 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (composting) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (incineration) | -1,282 | 338 | 1,619 |
| Society | Carbon Impacts (Landfill) | -60 | -160 | -100 |
| Local Authorities | Recycled material | 1,025 | 1,502 | 477 |
| Local Authorities | Composting costs | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Local Authorities | Energy from Waste costs | -7,829 | -8,327 | -499 |
| Local Authorities | Landfill costs | -264 | -298 | -34 |
| Local Authorities | Direct littering costs | -3,175 | -3,499 | -324 |
| Society | Indirect littering costs | -67,177 | -61,033 | 6,144 |
| Local Authorities | Residual waste | -5,299 | -5,851 | -552 |
| Society | Change in item costs | -1,168,467 | -1,185,360 | -16,893 |
| Total | -1,259,853 | -1,267,894 | -8,041 |
6. EPS containers
| Stakeholder | Impact | NPV under Baseline (£) | NPV under Option 1 (£) | Net change to NPV (£) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Society | Carbon impacts (production) | -686,977 | -642,755 | 44,222 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (recycling) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (composting) | 76 | 270 | 194 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (incineration) | -275,271 | -1,519 | 273,753 |
| Society | Carbon Impacts (Landfill) | -4,264 | -15,499 | -11,235 |
| Local Authorities | Recycled material | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Local Authorities | Composting costs | -2,188 | -7,754 | -5,567 |
| Local Authorities | Energy from Waste costs | -494,641 | -835,718 | -341,078 |
| Local Authorities | Landfill costs | -23,627 | -60,445 | -36,818 |
| Local Authorities | Direct littering costs | -90,232 | -153,884 | -63,652 |
| Society | Indirect littering costs | -2,025,479 | -2,024,168 | 1,311 |
| Local Authorities | Residual waste | -304,085 | -518,176 | -214,091 |
| Society | Change in item costs | -71,763,128 | -92,997,356 | -21,234,228 |
| Total | -71,763,128 | -92,997,356 | -21,234,228 |
7. EPS cups
| Stakeholder | Impact | NPV under Baseline (£) | NPV under Option 1 (£) | Net change to NPV (£) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Society | Carbon impacts (production) | -268,325 | -291,286 | -22,960 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (recycling) | 4,929 | 17,495 | 12,566 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (composting) | 4,929 | 17,495 | 12,566 |
| Society | Carbon impacts (incineration) | -94,219 | 24,729 | 118,949 |
| Society | Carbon Impacts (Landfill) | -1,462 | -5,311 | -3,849 |
| Local Authorities | Recycled material | 23,509 | 82,770 | 59,262 |
| Local Authorities | Composting costs | -13,125 | -46,526 | -33,401 |
| Local Authorities | Energy from Waste costs | -210,749 | -408,662 | -197,913 |
| Local Authorities | Landfill costs | -4,618 | -8,358 | -3,739 |
| Local Authorities | Direct littering costs | -42,984 | -91,029 | -48,045 |
| Society | Indirect littering costs | -1,381,008 | -1,380,115 | 894 |
| Local Authorities | Residual waste | -144,555 | -305,551 | -160,996 |
| Society | Change in item costs | -18,284,626 | -21,953,908 | -3,669,281 |
| Total | -20,412,306 | -24,348,255 | -3,935,949 |
Contact
Email: supd@gov.scot
There is a problem
Thanks for your feedback