Fairer Council Tax: consultation analysis

Analysis of responses to the Fairer Council Tax consultation.


Overview of responses received

The consultation remained open for submissions from 12 July 2023 to 20 September 2023 and received 15,628 responses. The majority of responses (99%, 15,547 respondents) were submitted through the online platform hosted by Citizen Space, while 81 responses (1%) were received directly via email.

Table 1. Responses by Source
Source Citizen Space Share
Citizen Space 15,547 99%
E-Mail 81 1%
All respondents 15,628 100%

The segmentation of the responses by Council Tax shows that the majority of respondents (86%) pay Council Tax for properties belonging to Bands E-H, which are the bands affected by the proposed increase, 8% of respondents are in Bands A-D, and 6% had other or no answers to this question. Overall, the most represented band is Band E, with 31% of respondents paying Council Tax in that band.

Table 2. Responses by Council Tax Band
Council Tax Band Count Share
Band A 91 1%
Band B 201 1%
Band C 261 2%
Band D 771 5%
Bands A-D 1,324 8%
Band E 4,778 31%
Band F 4,103 26%
Band G 3,899 25%
Band H 629 4%
Bands E-H 13,409 86%
Multiple bands 91 1%
I don't pay Council Tax 44 0%
I don’t know 537 3%
Not Answered 223 1%
Other 895 6%
All respondents 15,628 100%

The responses can be divided by respondent type as follows: (i) 15,537 (99.4%) responses from individuals, (ii) 87 (0.5%) responses from organisations, and (iii) 4 (<0.1%) responses where the respondent type was not stated. 15 responses were identified by the research team as being submitted on behalf of councils[7], and analysis of these responses have been presented separately for both closed-format and open-format questions.

Table 3. Responses by Respondent type
Respondent type Count Share
Individual 15,537 99.4%
Organisation 87 0.5%
Not Answered 4 <0.1%
All respondents 15,628 100%

The local authority area with the greatest number of respondents was Fife, followed by the City of Edinburgh and Glasgow City. The Shetland Islands, Na h-Eileanan Siar and the Orkney Islands had the fewest number of respondents.

Table 4. Responses by Local Authority
Council Tax Band Count Share
Fife Council 2,057 13.2%
City of Edinburgh Council 1,612 10.3%
Glasgow City Council 1,129 7.2%
East Renfrewshire Council 1,118 7.2%
South Lanarkshire Council 1,049 6.7%
Aberdeenshire Council 861 5.5%
Renfrewshire Council 631 4.0%
West Lothian Council 612 3.9%
North Lanarkshire Council 542 3.5%
East Dunbartonshire Council 522 3.3%
Aberdeen City Council 473 3.0%
Scottish Borders Council 470 3.0%
East Ayrshire Council 450 2.9%
Falkirk Council 445 2.8%
Midlothian Council 402 2.6%
East Lothian Council 391 2.5%
Perth & Kinross Council 331 2.1%
South Ayrshire Council 291 1.9%
Highland Council 263 1.7%
Stirling Council 251 1.6%
Dundee City Council 245 1.6%
North Ayrshire Council 236 1.5%
Dumfries & Galloway Council 198 1.3%
Inverclyde Council 154 1.0%
Angus Council 151 1.0%
Argyll & Bute Council 149 1.0%
Moray Council 124 0.8%
Clackmannanshire Council 118 0.8%
West Dunbartonshire Council 94 0.6%
Shetland Islands Council 35 0.2%
Whole of Scotland 24 0.2%
Comhairle nan Eilean Siar 13 0.1%
Orkney Islands Council 9 0.1%
Total 15,450[8] -

Contact

Email: ctconsultation@gov.scot

Back to top