Getting the best from our land - A land use stategy for Scotland Action Plan December 2011
Action Plan outlining how the Proposals in the Land Use Strategy will be taken forward. Includes information on how the Principles for Sustainable Land Use will be mainstreamed.
2. Delivery of the Strategy
2.1 The Principles for Sustainable Land Use
The Principles for Sustainable Land Use ( Annex A) reflect Government policies on the priorities which should inform land use choices across Scotland. The Strategy made clear that Government expects public bodies to use the Principles for Sustainable Land Use when making plans and taking significant decisions about the use of land. Where the private sector has significant land management responsibilities it is encouraged to do likewise.
Our view is that the Strategy provides a context for all decisions about land use and that the application of the Principles to decision-making will, over time, deliver the Strategy's Objectives. The Principles are the means of translating the high level aims of the Strategy into decision-making on the ground.
The decision-making processes for delivery are already in place across Scotland through a range of existing mechanisms such as Forestry and Woodland Strategies ( F&WS), development plans, River Basin Management Plans ( RBMP) or National Park Plans, along with a range of less formal approaches that suit the variety of different locations and circumstances across Scotland. Detailed policies and decisions for different parts of Scotland are matters which require local engagement and decisions. Application of the Principles at a local level will result in more consistent and integrated land use decisions and will enable communities to be better connected to the land, resilient and better able to adapt to the effects of a changing climate. One thing that all current processes have in common is that they rely heavily on a partnership approach in order to succeed. Partnership working is the key to successful delivery of an integrated, strategic approach to land use.
The Strategy also stated that we will work with existing processes and willing partners to determine what works best and where. We will evaluate the effectiveness of existing formal and informal delivery mechanisms at utilising the Principles as part of their everyday planning and decision-making. This will enable us to determine whether existing mechanisms are an effective tool for delivery of the Strategy and consider the lessons to be learned about applying the Principles in different circumstances and processes across Scotland. The outcome of this evaluation will provide a valuable insight into the effectiveness of the Strategy's current approach to delivery; translation of the high level Objectives into decision-making on the ground via the application of the Principles. This in turn will inform our thinking about decision-making processes for future reviews of the Land Use Strategy.
2.2 Delivery of the Proposals
This Action Plan focuses on the actions required to take forward delivery of the thirteen Proposals ( Annex B). The Strategy described the wider Government policies which contribute to the delivery of sustainable land use. We will ensure that our own policies, as they relate to land use, are aligned with the Strategy's Objectives and Principles. These plans and policies will be reviewed on an ongoing basis so as to align with the Strategy.
Each Proposal has a primary focus on research and evidence; guidance; or mainstreaming into policy. This is shown in Annex C: Indicative characteristics of Proposals. These classifications are indicative, showing the types of outcomes we are seeking and what delivery will look like for each Proposal.
Delivery of the Land Use Strategy Proposals requires good evidence and research. The Scottish Government Rural and Environment Science and Analytical Services Division ( RESAS) is funding a portfolio of Strategic Research over 2011-16 through its Main Research Providers ( MRPs).
This includes two five-year multidisciplinary research programmes:
- Environmental change programme
- Food, land and people programme
The RESAS research portfolio also includes Centres of Expertise and Strategic Partnerships.
Centres of Expertise:
- EPIC Centre of Expertise in Animal Diseases
- ClimateXChange
- Water
What follows is a summary of key factors for each Proposal:
- lead + key partners
- deliverables
- short term milestones
- long term milestones
- risks
Our SEARS partners have contributed to the development of this Action Plan and are key to the delivery of many of the Proposals outlined below. This Plan is dynamic, and the Government will review progress and communicate changes over time. The annual Progress Statement (Proposal 2), along with stakeholder input, will inform future development and revision of the Plan and in time the Strategy itself.
Proposals in the Land Use Strategy
Proposal 1 Publish an action plan following publication of the Strategy.
This Action Plan meets the requirement in Proposal 1. It has been developed in conjunction with our SEARS partners who will work with us to take forward delivery of the Proposals. We will review the need to update the Action Plan in the light of progress and if significant change has taken place we will publish an update to the Action Plan as appropriate.
Proposal 2 Provide an annual progress statement on the Land Use Strategy.
The annual Progress Statement will provide a snapshot view of progress with delivery of the Proposals and provide a commentary on wider delivery. It will be a key monitoring tool which will facilitate debate with all who have an interest in land use, as well as providing a focal point for collaborative thinking and action.
Objective 1
Proposal 3 Align land use regulations and incentives with Land Use Strategy Objectives.
The delivery of this Proposal focuses on the need to embed the Strategy's Principles for Sustainable Land Use into regulations and incentives. Close working across Government will ensure that clear policy linkages are made. We will work to ensure that all our incentives and regulations are effectively supporting the shift in approach identified in the Strategy towards the delivery of multiple benefits whilst also supporting our land-based businesses and placing as light a burden on business as possible.
Many regulations and incentives in the land-based sector are set within the context of EU legislation and directives, such as the Water Framework Directive, others are set within the framework of Scottish legislation. In all cases we will seek regulation that is proportionate and incentives that are efficient and cost effective.
Engagement with stakeholders will continue via existing groups and forums. Further consultation will take place as appropriate.
Lead + key partners | Scottish Government + SEPA, SNH, FCS. |
---|---|
Deliverables | The embedding of Land Use Strategy Principles into new regulatory approaches and incentives. Guidance document focusing on the Land Use Strategy Principles which is aimed at policy and decision makers in the land use environment. This will be designed to support the development of new legislative proposals and incentivisation initiatives. |
Short term milestones | Guidance
|
Long term milestones | Incorporation of Land Use Strategy Principles (where appropriate) in new legislation. |
Risks | Different stakeholders will have differing expectations of what successful delivery looks like. |
Objective 1
Proposal 4 Further encourage land-based businesses to take actions that reduce land-based greenhouse gas emissions and that enable adaptation to climate change threats and opportunities.
All business sectors in Scotland must consider how they can contribute to reducing greenhouse gas emissions in order to meet climate change targets. The land-based sector has a significant role to play and like other businesses across Scotland can also reap benefits from the opportunities that a changing climate presents. There is also a need to ensure that the land-based sector has the right skills in place developed through education and knowledge exchange to enable it to meet the challenges of adaptation.
The Farming For a Better Climate ( FFBC) initiative aims to support land managers in taking action on both climate change mitigation and adaptation. At this stage it seeks the maximum voluntary uptake of win-win actions which both reduce emissions and improve farm performance. Adopting measures like optimising nitrogen fertiliser management has multiple benefits, and can also help to achieve other environmental targets, including for example those for water and air quality. More broadly RBMPs already provide a major tool for taking forward a more integrated approach to water management. Action programmes have been put in place to address climate-sensitive pressures such as diffuse pollution from land use practices and abstraction for irrigation. An Agri-Renewables Strategy will consider key barriers to uptake of renewables on farms, supporting farm business as well as contributing to climate and renewables targets.
Other key policies relate to increased woodland planting ( see Proposal 7), peatland restoration ( Proposal 9) and measures under the Climate Change Adaptation Framework ( see Proposal 11).
Looking ahead we will continue to assist land managers actions on adaptation by working in partnership with stakeholders through forums such as the Agriculture & Climate Change Stakeholder Group. Water and water industry related groups such as the RBMP National Advisory Group, Diffuse Pollution Management Advisory Group, Area Advisory Groups, Fish and Fisheries Advisory Group, Scottish Advisory and Implementation Forum for Flooding are in place to consider issues that influence adaptation for the water sector and industries.
Lead + key partners | Scottish Government + FCS, SNH, SAC (Delivery Agency for FFBC), Agriculture and Climate Change Stakeholder Group, SEPA and partner organisations involved in River Basin Management and Flood Risk Management Planning. |
---|---|
Deliverables |
|
Short term milestones |
|
Long term milestones |
|
Risks | Lack of uptake by land managers; voluntary initiatives fail to have impact. |
Objective 1
Proposal 5 Use the Land Use Strategy Objectives to influence negotiations on CAP reform.
We recognise the importance of the revision of the EU Common Agricultural Policy ( CAP) for land-based businesses such as agriculture and forestry, and for other policy objectives such as biodiversity, environmental quality, recreation and rural communities. Although the land-based sector is driven by outside influences such as commodity markets the CAP is the key factor in terms of influencing individual land manger choices about land use.
The Objectives of the Land Use Strategy will help shape our input to CAP negotiations at EU and UK level and will inform our thinking when developing the detail of the incentives regime for Scotland. This work is at an early stage with draft EU Regulations published in October 2011, the timetable for delivery will be driven by EU processes. We will continue to work with stakeholders throughout the CAP reform process via the CAP Stakeholder Group and relevant subgroups.
Lead + key partners | Scottish Government + SEARS partners and CAP Stakeholder Group. |
---|---|
Deliverables | A revised CAP that enables the Strategy's Objectives and Principles to be delivered via the new incentives regime post 2013. |
Short term milestones |
|
Long term milestones |
|
Risks | Expectations exceed what is permitted or likely to be permitted across all 27 Member States. Disproportionate EU bureaucracy associated with sustainable land use. |
Objective 1
Proposal 6 Use demonstration projects to determine the best means by which land use and land management practice can contribute to climate change objectives.
Scotland already has a good record of sharing good practice and live demonstration projects to share expertise and knowledge. It is vital that we continue to trial new approaches, monitor their success and then share the results of that success and ensure that it is applicable across Scotland, for example the SNH'Sharing Good Practice' events are an important link between policy and practice.
Focus Farms attract land managers to events and receive good press coverage. It is important that the benefits of these events are widely communicated to enable as many land managers as possible to benefit. We will continue to work with our stakeholders to refine and develop communication methods so as to meet their needs.
The Central Scotland Green Network ( CSGN) has also identified responding to climate change as one of its key outcomes and will be facilitating a range of land use projects to demonstrate in practice the contribution of multi-functional green networks.
Lead + key partners | Scottish Government and FCS + SAC (the delivery agency for FFBC and Climate Change Focus Farms) and the Agriculture & Climate Change Stakeholder Group. |
---|---|
Deliverables | Focus Farms are leaders in sustainable farm practices, including creating and managing farm woodlands. Land managers actively utilise them as they adopt climate friendly farm management. |
Short term milestones |
|
Long term milestones |
|
Risks | Lack of uptake by land managers; voluntary initiatives fails to have impact; farm advice landscape is cluttered, with too many initiatives operating in isolation. |
Objective 1
Proposal 7 Identify more closely which types of land are best for tree planting in the context of other land-based objectives, and promote good practice and local processes in relation to tree planting so as to secure multiple benefits.
We wish to increase woodland creation to 10,000 hectares per year, but are mindful that this needs to be achieved in a way which is integrated with other land-based objectives such as agriculture and food production, climate change, rural development, renewable energy, biodiversity, soil, water, deer, green networks, historic environment and landscape.
In August 2011 the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and the Environment established the Woodland Expansion Advisory Group ( WEAG) with the purpose of taking forward delivery of this Proposal. The WEAG is charged with advising him, by June 2012, on which types of land are best for tree planting in the context of other land-based objectives, and on related good practice and local processes.
This Proposal will be taken forward against a backdrop of CAP reform and potential changes to the incentive regime for new planting and the fluctuation of world markets for timber and timber products. The involvement of stakeholders in forestry is crucial and the continuing role of Scottish Forestry Forum and Regional Forestry Forums will be emphasised in order to continue to deliver multiple benefits as well as new planting.
Lead + key partners | FCS + a range of other partners include members of WEAG which consists of farming, forestry, conservation, community and land experts. |
---|---|
Deliverables |
|
Short term milestones | Woodland Expansion Advisory Group:
|
Long term milestones | Dependent upon WEAG final report and consideration by Cabinet Secretary, a subsequent action plan will set out longer term milestones. |
Risks | Planting targets not achieved due to land managers not taking up incentives to plant trees and conflicts with other land use interests. |
Objective 2
Proposal 8 Demonstrate how the ecosystem approach could be taken into account in relevant decisions made by public bodies to deliver wider benefits, and provide practical guidance.
We have published an Information Note on ' Applying an ecosystems approach to land use'. This is aimed at public bodies involved in land use decision-making but is also of interest to land managers and NGOs. It outlines the integrated principles and practical applications of an ecosystems approach in delivering a wider range of sustainable benefits from our land.
An ecosystems and ecosystems services approach to decision-making is increasingly favoured by the European Commission and is being built into a wide spectrum of environmental policies related to biodiversity, integrated catchment management, the marine environment and air quality. Delivery of the Land Use Strategy will reflect the best practice ecosystems approaches being taken forward through relevant aspects of these policies. Development of the National Ecological Network will help ensure land management decisions are better targeted to delivering ecosystem services and support climate change adaptation. Across Central Scotland, action will be focused on the delivery of multifunctional green networks by the CSGN.
The Scottish Government Strategic Research Programme will support the wider adoption of the ecosystem approach. This is linked to Proposal 10, as research will support both practical steps to improve individual decisions and decision-making processes, and research into the analytical needs and broader implications of a fully-fledged ecosystem approach. It is also linked to Proposal 6, by linking guidance with demonstration projects that show the benefits of the ecosystem approach in practice.
The Scottish Biodiversity Strategy is under review. It will reflect new international targets that place the maintenance of the levels of ecosystem services alongside the preservation of species and habitat diversity as headline goals.
Lead + key partners | Scottish Government + the MRPs, FCS, SEPA, SNH, Centre for Ecology and Hydrology ( CEH) and the Centres of Expertise. |
---|---|
Deliverables |
|
Short term milestones |
|
Long term milestones |
|
Risks | Decision makers do not recognise that an ecosystems approach has something to offer them in improving decisions. The additional information requirements may put some decision makers off using the approach. |
Objective 2
Proposal 9 Develop a methodology to take account of changes in soil carbon for carbon accounting purposes; improve understanding of potential benefits from conservation and management of carbon-rich soils; and deliver measures to help secure long-term management of all land-based carbon stores.
This Proposal will build on a range of existing work. In March 2011 SEPA co-ordinated publication of a report on The State of Scotland's Soils, which followed a discussion paper on carbon-rich soils in December 2010 by the Scottish Government. The aim of the Proposal is to make accounting of changes in soil carbon part of the overall framework of land use decision-making and promote measures for long-term management of soils rich in carbon. SNH is developing with partners a programme for peatland restoration and enhancement.
Achieving that aim requires action not only in Scotland, supported by resources such as the Government's Strategic Research Programme, but also through our involvement with, and influencing of, international actions and decision-making.
The Soils Focus Group is a key forum for this work within Scotland. Initiatives such as the Woodland Carbon Code and associated reporting guidelines are important for both Scotland and the UK. We will engage with EU-level CAP reform discussions, and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change ( IPCC) on emissions reporting.
Lead + key partners | Scottish Government + DECC, Defra, CEH, MRPs, FCS, SEPA, SNH, SAC, ClimateXChange, Centre of Expertise on Water, NGOs. |
---|---|
Deliverables |
|
Short term milestones |
|
Long term milestones |
|
Risks | Failure to deliver evidence to promote scientific consensus. Method agreement required at future UNFCCCCOP meetings. Funding of proposed measures not secured. |
Objective 2
Proposal 10 Investigate the relationship between land management changes and ecosystem processes to identify adaptation priorities.
This proposal responds to a research requirement to identify and understand the relationships between ecosystem functions and services and land management practices. Improved information on these relationships will better enable land use in Scotland to meet the challenges of adapting to a changing world. In particular, the proposal seeks to investigate the ability to sustain beneficial ecosystem services and to identify trade-offs between these within the context of changing land management. This is a cross-cutting proposal which links to other proposals in the Land Use Strategy (notably Proposal 8) and in addition to a range of environmental and rural policy areas.
Achieving this understanding requires substantial research and stakeholder engagement. The Ecosystem Approach Working Group is a key forum for this work. Of particular relevance to this proposal is the environmental change programme of the Scottish Government Strategic Research Programme and the new Scottish Centres of Expertise.
Lead + key partners | Scottish Government + the MRPs, FCS, SEPA, SNH, CEH, Centres of Expertise. |
---|---|
Deliverables |
|
Short term milestones |
|
Long term milestones |
|
Risks | Ecosystem processes are dynamic and complex. Data limitation in some areas. Difficulties in handling uncertainty. Failure to deliver evidence with sufficient scientific consensus. |
Objective 3
Proposal 11 Develop the land use aspects of our Climate Change Adaptation Framework to support communities as they adapt to change.
The Adaptation Framework is the non-statutory forerunner to the Adaptation Programme required by the Climate Change (Scotland) Act. It established 12 Sector Action Plans which identify the climate change issues and challenges for each sector and provide a list of planned work to strengthen resilience to the impacts of climate change.
Delivery of this Proposal is dependent on each individual sector. Future work may be required to identify new actions in the Sector Action Plans which will enhance the land use aspects which support communities. In Central Scotland, a key mechanism for delivery of these actions will be the CSGN.
The Scottish Adaptation Programme, as required under the above Act will be introduced in 2013. The actions in the current Sector Action Plans are a baseline from which we will begin to work with communities as they respond to climate change. When the Scottish Adaptation Framework is published we will be able to develop and refine our actions in response.
Lead + key partners |
Scottish Government and FCS adaptation sector leads. |
---|---|
Deliverables |
The land use aspects of the Adaptation Framework that support communities in current actions in Sector Plans. Examples which have links to land use and communities are:
|
Short term milestones |
|
Long term milestones |
Many of the actions in the Sector Action Plans will be delivered before 2013; land use will feature as appropriate in the Scottish Adaptation Programme post 2013. |
Risks |
Current actions from the Sector Action Plans are not taken forward. |
Objective 3
Proposal 12 Identify and publicise effective ways for communities to contribute to land use debates and decision-making.
We wish to provide all communities with the opportunity to find out how land is used, have a voice in debates over the land's future and where possible get involved in managing the land themselves. This Proposal aims to provide a resource for the public to access information regarding the various statutory and non-statutory opportunities available to influence land use related plans and decisions. Good practice examples will demonstrate how these processes can be made most effective. The publicity and collation of good practice and advice may be aided through the delivery of Proposal 13.
We are committed to enhancing the involvement of communities in the use of land and decisions made regarding it. A Community Empowerment and Renewal Bill is being taken forward to support communities taking over unused or underused public sector assets and promote communities participation in the design and delivery of public services.
The variety of interests involved in land use debates from communities, land managers, industry and government, mean that there are numerous linkages within government policy, from planning to forestry, National Parks, energy to River Basin Management Planning and many more. In delivering this Proposal government and agency consultations will make appropriate links to the Land Use Strategy and its Principles.
Lead + key partners | Scottish Government + FCS, SNH, SEPA, local and National Park Authorities. |
---|---|
Deliverables |
|
Short term milestones |
|
Long term milestones | Resources, channels of communication and examples of good practice will be updated as they develop and change. |
Risks | Lack of really good examples of good practice. Communities fail to actively engage. |
Objective 3
Proposal 13 Provide a Land Use Information Hub on the Scottish Government website.
We would like people to have greater access to information, guidance and opportunities to contribute to debates about land use. A multi agency project titled SEWeb has been developed as a focal point for environmental data. It is being developed as a first port of call for anyone looking for reliable and accurate information on Scotland's environment.
The site will provide access to data held and managed by a wide range of organisations across Scotland. It will bring together and analyse data from different sources and present this in an accessible form.
The site will also directly involve users in developing our understanding of the environment and improving the way we protect it, through citizen science. The project has gained LIFE funding to develop the public involvement in the collection, use and understanding of environmental data.
Lead + key partners | SEPA + a range of data-holding partners including Scottish Government, Historic Scotland, SNH, MRPs, Environment Link, NHS, FCS and many others. |
---|---|
Deliverables |
|
Short term milestones |
|
Long term milestones | SEWeb is a long-term project currently planned over five years (2010/11 to 2015/16). It will be developed progressively in terms of the data it holds and the functionality of the site. The LIFE funding will be used to develop a 3 year programme of public engagement and involvement in environmental monitoring and action. |
Risks | Communication of the site and its functionality fails to engage the wider public. |
There is a problem
Thanks for your feedback