Stakeholder |
Type |
LA area |
FP Bill Consultation |
EES consultation |
Call for evidence |
Oral Evidence |
Summary |
Argyll and Bute |
Council |
Argyll and Bute |
- need rural MIS
- health of building not age of occupier (s)
- extra consideration to be given to hard to treat properties
- efforts needed to reduce fuel costs
|
- those with no access to the gas grid are most likely to be FP however measures for them are most likely to not be cost effective or technically feasible
- remote rural/island issues still to be addressed
|
- concerned disproportionate amount of residual 5% will be rural households
- rural MIS
|
- enhanced heating age threshold slightly high
- importance of people on the ground
- 2040 target realistic
- local authority targets feasible in Argyll and Bute for fuel poverty
- welcome an extreme fuel poverty target
|
- RR MIS
- off grid hard to treat will fall into bottom 5%
- fuel costs
- health of buildings not age of occupiers
- enhanced heating threshold too high and arbitrary
- people on the ground
- extreme fuel poverty target
|
Comhairle Nan Eilean Sar |
Council |
Comhairle Nan Eilean Sar |
- need rural MIS
- definition to island proofed
- pension age to be used if using age for enhanced heating
|
|
- remote rural MIS
- island proofing
|
|
- RRMIS
- island proofing
- pension age for enhanced heating
|
Highland |
Council |
Highland |
- need rural MIS
- uplift for LT sick / or disabled
- need for flexibility of funding streams and on the practical delivery
- other ways of taking into account the poorer health outcomes if age raised to 75
- targeting of extreme FP households
|
- additional support for RR areas
- funding for homeowners in fuel and income poverty
|
- RR MIS
- Home maintenance costs to be included in calculation
- strategy to be island proofed
- Extreme FP target
|
|
- RR MIS
- funding flexibility
- additional criteria for poor health
- extreme FP target
- funding for homeowners
- home maintenance costs
- island proofing
|
North Ayrshire |
Council |
North Ayrshire |
- exceptions for those with no rent or mortgage payments but surviving on low in come and have high fuel costs
- new state pension age of 68. Have high levels of deprivation in catchment area
|
NA (fed back however not relevant to ICIA) |
NA |
|
- no rent/mortgage but low income
- enhanced heating age 68
|
Orkney (has own target of getting FP in Orkney to the national average by 2022 and eradicating by 2032) |
Council |
Orkney |
- need for rural MIS
- project flexibility to reflect local issues
- generic age unfair due to lower life expectancy rates in some areas
- high fuel pricing in some areas
|
NA |
NA |
|
- rural MIS
- project flexibility
- no age on enhanced heating
- high fuel prices
|
Shetland Islands |
Council |
Shetland |
- need for rural MIS
- age is a blunt tool for enhanced heating - elderly to lose out
- fuel prices
|
NA |
|
|
- rural MIS
- elderly losing out higher age
- island proofing
- fuel pricing
|
Hebridean Housing Association |
Housing Association |
Comhairle Nan Eilean Sar |
- need for rural MIS
- extreme FP
- island proofing
- arbitrary age is lazy, health and care services should ID criteria
|
NA |
NA |
|
- need for rural MIS
- extreme FP
- island proofing
- arbitrary age is lazy, health and care services should ID criteria
|
Lochalsh and Skye Housing Association |
Housing Association |
Highland |
- need for rural MIS
- arbitrary age is discriminatory to those communities whose life expectancy varies negatively from others
|
NA |
NA |
|
- need for rural MIS
- arbitrary age is discriminatory to those communities whose life expectancy varies negatively from others
|
Orkney Housing Association |
Housing Association |
Orkney |
- need for remote rural MIS
- arbitrary age - adverse impact on rural and island areas which have higher % of elderly vs urban areas
|
NA |
- remote rural MIS
- longer term funding for SG programmes
|
|
- need for remote rural MIS
- arbitrary age
- adverse impact on rural and island areas which have higher % of elderly vs urban areas
- longer term funding for SG programmes
|
Rural and Islands Housing Association Forum (RIHAF) |
Housing Association |
Scotland |
|
NA |
- rural MIS
- island proofing of strategy
|
|
- rural MIS
- island proofing of strategy
|
Highland and Islands Housing Associations Affordable Warmth Partners Group |
Partnership or interagency group |
Highland |
- need for rural MIS
- inclusion in MIS of adjustment for LT sick or disabled
- how to include agricultural tenancies (strategy though)
- age 75 - issue of impact on pensioners with no mortgage to pay but high fuel costs
|
NA |
- remote rural MIS
- island proofing of strategy
- extreme FP target
|
- helpful to continue to measure extreme fuel poverty and to eradicate within 5 years
- inclusion of remote rural MIS
- 2032 instead of 2040
- improved understanding of outcomes rather than inputs
- importance of front line people
- island proofing
|
- remote rural MIS
- island proofing
- MIS adjustment for LT sick and disabled
- agricultural tenancies?
- 75 - impact on pensioners with no mortgage but high energy costs
- extreme FP target
- 2032 target
- improved understanding of outcomes
- front line people
|
THAW Orkney |
Partnership or interagency group |
Orkney |
- need for remote rural MIS
- definition of 'vulnerable'
- arbitrary movement of age - further research needed
|
- difficult to treat properties should not be exempt from having work done when household is in FP
|
NA (fed back however not relevant to ICIA) |
|
- need for remote rural MIS
- definition of 'vulnerable'
- arbitrary movement of age - further research needed
- difficult to treat properties should not be exempt from having work done when household is in FP
|
Highlands and Islands Enterprise Agency |
Other |
Highland |
- need for remote rural MIS
|
Na |
NA |
|
|
Shetland Fuel Poverty Group |
Partnership or interagency group |
Shetland |
- need for rural MIS
- age is a blunt tool for enhanced heating - elderly to lose out
- fuel prices
|
NA |
|
|
- rural MIS
- elderly losing out higher age
- island proofing
- fuel pricing
|
Tighean Innse Gall (TIG) Western Isles |
Third Sector |
Comhairle Nan Eilean Sar |
- health and vulnerability links should be further assessed before new definition is implemented
- need for a remote rural MIS
- greater flexibility in the per house spending limits that currently exist
- Age threshold is arbitrary and not based upon evidence. Should not be implemented until further research undertaken
|
- no cap per household on expenditure for energy efficiency
|
|
|
- health and vulnerability links should be further assessed before new definition is implemented
- need for a remote rural MIS
- greater flexibility in the per house spending limits that currently exist
- Age threshold is arbitrary and not based upon evidence. Should not be implemented until further research undertaken
|
Public Health in NHS Ayrshire and Arran |
Health and Social Care |
North Ayrshire |
- Enhanced heating regime should be available for over 65's, those with a long term underlying health condition (eg those as risk groups for flue, children and adults with weakened immune systems and families with children living in private rented accommodation.
|
|
|
|
- Enhanced heating regime should be available for over 65's, those with a long term underlying health condition (eg those as risk groups for flue, children and adults with weakened immune systems and families with children living in private rented accommodation.
|
Scottish Islands Federation |
Partnership or interagency group |
Scotland |
- new definition will omit categories of households in rural areas and islands in particular
- need for a rural MIS
- Use of AHC, MIS and increased threshold of 75 years may have an unintended and disproportionate impact on island and rural communities
|
|
|
|
- new definition will omit categories of households in rural areas and islands in particular
- need for a rural MIS
- Use of AHC, MIS and increased threshold of 75 years may have an unintended and disproportionate impact on island and rural communities
|
Argyll and Bute Energy Forum |
Partnership or interagency group |
Argyll and Bute |
|
- issue of off gas grid households that aren't technically feasible and cost effective - however most likely to be in FP
- lack of rural, remote and island MIS
|
|
|
- issue of off gas grid households that aren't technically feasible and cost effective - however most likely to be in FP
- lack of rural, remote and island MIS
|
Jura Community |
Other |
Argyll and Bute |
|
|
- need for remote rural MIS
- island proofing
|
|
- need for remote rural MIS
- island proofing
|