Publication - Progress report
The land of Scotland and the common good: report
The final report of the Land Reform Review Group.
Annex 3
Land Reform Review Group
LIST OF PUBLISHED SUBMISSIONS
The Land Reform Review Group issued a Call for Evidence on 4th October 2012. By the close of the Call for Evidence on 18th January 2103, the Group had received a total of 484 submissions. 321 of these were published (56 anonymously) and are listed below. The remaining 163 were not published, because either privacy was requested by the respondents (93) or the respondents failed to return a Respondent Information Form authorising publication.
During this Call for Evidence period, the Group also visited several areas of Scotland and had meetings with a variety of different interests. As part of this, the Group arranged public events and open meetings in:
Greenock 12th November 2012
Tarbert, Harris 11th December 2012
Fort William 12th December 2012
Dumfries 10th January 2013
Glasgow 27th February 2013
Published Submissions [1]
| Ref No | Name / Organisation |
|---|---|
| 1 | Greenspace Scotland |
| 2 | Scotland's Rural College ( SRUC) |
| 3 | Scottish Branch, Chartered Institute of Arbitrators |
| 8 | John Muir Trust |
| 9 | Di Alexander |
| 13 | Ian Thomas |
| 15 | East Ayrshire Council |
| 16 | Orkney Islands Council |
| 18 | Sir Peter Hutchison |
| 19 | Anonymous |
| 20 | Robbie Pennington |
| 21 | Scottish Anglers National Association |
| 23 | Julia Campbell |
| 26 | Reforesting Scotland |
| 27 | South Lanarkshire Horse And Pony Access Group |
| 28 | Hazel Cameron |
| 29 | Centre for Human Ecology |
| 30 | Derek Pretswell |
| 31 | Jamie McIntyre |
| 32 | Jamie McKenzie Hamilton |
| 33 | Leith Community Crops in Pots |
| 34 | Jonathan Agnew |
| 35 | Anonymous |
| 36 | Henry Trotter |
| 37 | Sideactivity |
| 38 | Alex Gordon-Duff |
| 39 | Scottish Land & Estates |
| 40 | Anonymous |
| 41 | Scottish Natural Heritage |
| 42 | Anonymous |
| 43 | North East Mountain Trust |
| 44 | Anonymous |
| 45 | Oxfam |
| 46 | Dr Robert McMorran |
| 48 | Ross Paton |
| 49 | Scottish Tenant Farmers Association |
| 50 | Steve James |
| 52 | East Lothian Council |
| 53 | Eadha Enterprises |
| 54 | Riddell Estate |
| 56 | Kinnordy Estate |
| 58 | Ron Greer |
| 59 | John Sinclair |
| 60 | Ludwig Appeltans |
| 61 | Anonymous |
| 62 | Comhairle nan Eilean Siar |
| 63 | Rio Tinto Alcan |
| 64 | Highland Council |
| 65 | Laurence Keeley |
| 69 | Tenant Farming Forum |
| 70 | Paul Cochrane |
| 73 | Anonymous |
| 74 | Dunnichen Community Company |
| 75 | Arran Centre for Strategic Land Use |
| 79 | I.M.M.Crichton |
| 81 | Shared Voices Group |
| 84 | Malcolm Combe |
| 89 | John MacKintosh |
| 90 | Association of Deer Management Groups |
| 93 | James Hutton Institute |
| 94 | Anonymous |
| 96 | Womens Land Reform Group |
| 100 | Alastair Riddell |
| 101 | Stonefield Farms |
| 102 | R Coleman |
| 103 | Balnamoon Farms Co |
| 104 | Joyce Bruce |
| 105 | Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations |
| 106 | Church of Scotland |
| 107 | Highlands & Islands Enterprise |
| 108 | Anonymous |
| 109 | Historic Houses Association |
| 110 | The Applecross Trust |
| 111 | Anonymous |
| 114 | Nourish Scotland |
| 115 | Shinness Estate |
| 116 | Scottish Rights of Way and Access Society (ScotWays) |
| 117 | Andrew Finlayson |
| 118 | Vanessa Halhead |
| 119 | John Thomas |
| 120 | CTC scotland |
| 121 | Planning Aid for Scotland |
| 122 | Scottish Crofting Federation |
| 123 | Anonymous |
| 124 | Southern Uplands Partnership |
| 125 | Anonymous |
| 129 | Val Robson |
| 130 | Highland Perthshire Communities Land Trust |
| 131 | Stewart Jamieson |
| 132 | Anonymous |
| 133 | Anonymous |
| 134 | Mary Howlett |
| 135 | Ian Gillies |
| 136 | Aigas Community Forest |
| 137 | North Harris Trust |
| 138 | Catherine Francis |
| 140 | Northern Deer Management Group |
| 141 | Ekklesia |
| 142 | Prof Denis Mollison |
| 143 | Calum MacLeod |
| 145 | Confederation of Forest Industries |
| 147 | Gilbert Bannerman |
| 148 | Jamie Roberts |
| 149 | Andy Wightman |
| 150 | Anonymous |
| 152 | Forest Policy Group, wild deer management |
| 153 | UPM Tilhill |
| 154 | Forest Policy Group, forestry reform |
| 155 | Comrie Croft |
| 156 | Deirdre Stewart |
| 157 | Scottish Borders Council |
| 159 | Anonymous |
| 161 | Anonymous |
| 162 | Ronald MacLean |
| 163 | Alasdair Laing |
| 165 | Community Woodlands Association |
| 166 | Centre for Rural Development |
| 167 | Sue Hilder |
| 168 | Islay Estates Company |
| 169 | Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors |
| 172 | Scottish Agricultural Arbiters & Valuers Association |
| 173 | Wemyss Estates Trustees |
| 176 | The Crown Estate |
| 180 | Loch Choire Estate |
| 181 | Anonymous |
| 182 | NFUS |
| 185 | Ramblers Scotland |
| 186 | Andy Inglis |
| 187 | Wemyss and March Estates |
| 188 | The National Trust for Scotland |
| 189 | Donna Mackenzie |
| 193 | Rural Housing Service |
| 194 | Strutt & Parker LLP |
| 196 | Michael Foxley |
| 197 | Richard Callander |
| 198 | Anonymous |
| 199 | Anonymous |
| 200 | Game & Wildlife Conservation Trust |
| 201 | Andrew Hamilton |
| 203 | Shelter Scotland |
| 206 | Royal Town Planning Institute Scotland |
| 207 | Scottish Water |
| 208 | Malcolm Nicol |
| 209 | Anonymous |
| 210 | Scottish Community Alliance |
| 211 | Glenernie Estate |
| 213 | Anonymous |
| 215 | Anonymous |
| 216 | Loch Lomond & The Trossachs National Park |
| 219 | Anonymous |
| 220 | Alastair Riddell |
| 221 | Anonymous |
| 222 | Development Trusts Association Scotland |
| 223 | Scottish Sports Association |
| 224 | Anonymous |
| 226 | Moray Estates |
| 227 | Malcolm Younger |
| 230 | Mark laing |
| 231 | Lianne Hackett & Chris Fremantle |
| 233 | Colin Corlett |
| 234 | Association for the Protection of Rural Scotland |
| 235 | Stirling Council & Stirling Area Local Access Forum |
| 236 | Cromar Community Council |
| 237 | West Harris Trust |
| 241 | Woodland Crofts Partnership |
| 242 | Bowhill and Dalkeith Estates of Buccleuch Estates |
| 243 | Anonymous |
| 247 | Scottish Council for Development and Industry |
| 248 | Carnegie UK Trust |
| 249 | British Horse Society |
| 250 | Association of Salmon Fishery Boards |
| 251 | Mark Nicolson |
| 252 | Smiths Gore |
| 253 | Dr Jayne Glass |
| 255 | Sustrans Scotland |
| 256 | Richard Stirling-Aird |
| 257 | Blair Atholl & Struan Community Council |
| 258 | Achentoul Estate Company Ltd & Achentoul Farms Ltd |
| 259 | RSPB Scotland |
| 260 | Anonymous |
| 262 | Trustees of Cawdor Maintenance Trust, Cawdor Estate |
| 263 | Brian Inkster |
| 264 | Anonymous |
| 265 | Alexander Baillie |
| 266 | Robert Balfour |
| 268 | Scottish Allotments and Gardens Society |
| 269 | Joe Gibbs |
| 271 | Haddington Estate |
| 272 | Roxburghe Estate |
| 272A | Duke of Roxburghe |
| 273 | Eilidh I.M. Ross |
| 274 | Dunecht Estates |
| 277 | James Baillie |
| 280 | Philip Astor |
| 281 | Lord Balniel |
| 282 | Queensberry Estate |
| 284 | Anonymous |
| 285 | Anonymous |
| 287 | Esk District Salmon Fishery Board |
| 288 | Daye Tucker |
| 289 | Richard Sidgwick |
| 290 | Nordic Enterprise Trust |
| 291 | Kinghorn Community Land Association |
| 293 | Brian Marden |
| 294 | Andrew T Wood |
| 295 | Anonymous |
| 296 | Scottish Woodlot Association |
| 298 | Tom Gray |
| 300 | Caledonia Centre for Social Development |
| 302 | Douglas & Angus Estates |
| 303 | Andrew Salvesen |
| 305 | Anonymous |
| 307 | David Robertson |
| 308 | James Galbraith |
| 310 | Anonymous |
| 311 | Anonymous |
| 313 | William Parente |
| 314 | Law Society of Scotland rural sub-committee |
| 315 | Seafield and Strathspey Estates |
| 317 | Community Land Scotland |
| 320 | James Baillie |
| 321 | Justin Kenrick |
| 325 | Greens Chartered Surveyors |
| 326 | Scottish Outdoor Access Network |
| 328 | Know Edge Ltd |
| 329 | Peter Landale |
| 330 | Euan J. Webster |
| 331 | Big Lottery |
| 332 | The Mountaineering Council of Scotland |
| 333 | Noel Darlow |
| 336 | Scottish Countryside Alliance |
| 337 | Kevin Findlater |
| 339 | Dr Jean Balfour |
| 342 | Mid West Association of Highland Estates Deer Management Group |
| 346 | John Digney |
| 347 | British Association for Shooting and Conservation |
| 350 | Scottish Canoe Association |
| 351 | The MacRobert Trust |
| 353 | Society of Local Government Lawyers and Administrators in Scotland |
| 355 | Anonymous |
| 357 | Anonymous |
| 358 | Holmehill Community Buyout Group |
| 359 | Glenfalloch Estate |
| 361 | Scottish Land & Estates Moorland Group |
| 364 | Bidwells |
| 366 | Donna Skelly |
| 368 | Arthur Greenan |
| 369 | Storas Uibhist Ltd |
| 370 | Anonymous |
| 372 | Anonymous |
| 373 | Anonymous |
| 375 | J. Martin Haldane |
| 376 | Stracathro and Careston Estate |
| 377 | Alvie & Dalraddy Estates |
| 378 | Atholl Estates |
| 379 | Drummuir Estate |
| 380 | Balloch Riders Access Group |
| 382 | Anonymous |
| 384 | Lochcarron Estate |
| 385 | Richard Cooke |
| 387 | Torwoodlee and Buckholm Estate |
| 388 | William John Buchanan |
| 392 | Anthony Foyle |
| 393 | Anonymous |
| 394 | Martin Girvan |
| 395 | Anonymous |
| 399 | Anonymous |
| 400 | Jack Whitaker |
| 401 | Peter Graham |
| 402 | Anonymous |
| 403 | Friends of Loch Lomond and The Trossachs |
| 404 | Embo Trust |
| 406 | John Macdonald |
| 407 | Andrew Lorrain-Smith |
| 408 | James Duncan Millar |
| 409 | Anonymous |
| 410 | Ewan G Kennedy |
| 412 | Ewen MacPherson |
| 413 | Helmsdale District Salmon Fishery Board |
| 414 | Argyll and Bute Local Access Forum |
| 415 | Anonymous |
| 416 | Cove Harbour Conservation |
| 419 | Anonymous |
| 421 | Anonymous |
| 423 | Kincardine Estate |
| 425 | Prof. Colin T. Reid and Dr. Walters Nsoh |
| 426 | Prof Jane Bower |
| 427 | Michael Wigan |
| 428 | Anonymous |
| 431 | Hawick & Jedburgh Branch of NFUS |
| 432 | Anonymous |
| 434 | Woodland Trust Scotland |
| 435 | Glenmuick Estate |
| 436 | Edward Baxter |
| 437 | Dunbeath Estate |
| 438 | John Randall |
| 440 | Stratherrick and Foyers Community Trust |
| 443 | RHS Gordon |
| 444 | Mark Crichton Maitland |
| 445 | Anonymous |
| 446 | Graham Tuley |
| 447 | Colin Strang Steel, Threepwood |
| 448 | Jamie Orr Ewing |
| 449 | Marion Boyle |
| 452 | Anonymous |
| 453 | Anonymous |
| 455 | J & S Grant |
| 458 | Alexander Gordon Morison |
| 459 | Druidaig Estate |
| 463 | Dormont Estate |
| 465 | Miff Tuck |
| 467 | Cambo Estate |
| 470 | Anonymous |
| 471 | Hopes Estate |
| 475 | Michael Maciocia |
| 477 | Scottish Federation of Housing Associations |
| 478 | Reginald Melton |
| 480 | Anonymous |
| 481 | Highlands Small Communities Housing Trust |
| 482 | Environmental NGOs, Centre for Mountain Studies |
| 483 | Scottish Environment LINK |
| 484 | David Merrick |
Contact
There is a problem
Thanks for your feedback