National Risk Framework to Support the Assessment of Children and Young People
The document is a national risk assessment 'toolkit' for child protection to support practioners in identifying and acting on child protection risks in children and young people.
Risk Indicator Sheets
Generic Risk Indicators
(Child, Parent/Carer and Wider World)
Matrix Related Risk Indicators
(Child, Parent/Carer and Wider World)
- Resilience
- Adversity
- Vulnerability
- Protective
Resistance Related Risk Indicators
(Child, Parent/Carer and Wider World)
Generic Risk Indicators
A collection of Generic Risk Indicators drawn from research and practice that help highlight potential risk factors within a child's/young person's life circumstances relative to the three dimensions of assessment within the My World Triangle - the child (how I grow and develop), parent/carer (what I need from the people who care for me) and their wider world.
Generic Risk Indicators
Risk Indicators Particular to the Child (How I Grow and Develop)
Generic Indicators - The Child | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Child 4 | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Premature birth/ low birth weight | |||||
Early prolonged separation at birth | |||||
Baby born with substance withdrawal (NAS) | |||||
Very young - highly dependent (birth - 5 years) | |||||
Cries frequently, difficult to comfort | |||||
Difficulties in feeding/toileting | |||||
Periods of separation from parent/primary caregiver | |||||
Adopted or step-child | |||||
Fostered | |||||
Child developmental delay | |||||
Child mental health difficulties | |||||
Child learning disabilities | |||||
Child behavioural difficulties | |||||
Difficult temperament | |||||
Health issues requiring ongoing medical treatment | |||||
Engaging in self-harm | |||||
Involved in substance misuse | |||||
Anti-social behaviour/relationships | |||||
Involved in offending | |||||
Evidence sexually inappropriate behaviour | |||||
Poor relationship with parents | |||||
Fearful of parent/caregiver | |||||
Outwith parental control | |||||
Child not seen by or given chance to talk to workers | |||||
Contested contact and residence issues | |||||
Repeat victim | |||||
Historical abuse of siblings by carers | |||||
Direct or indirect exposure to domestic abuse | |||||
Statutory or CP measures in place | |||||
Poor school attendance | |||||
Young Carer | |||||
English is not first language of child | |||||
More than 4 children in the family |
Risk Indicators Particular to the Parent/Carer
(What I Need from the People Who Look after Me)
Generic Indicators - Parent/Carer | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Child 4 | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Parent under 21 years | |||||
Poor parenting skills | |||||
Poor understanding of child's needs | |||||
Lack of empathy | |||||
Unrealistic expectations of child (age & stage) | |||||
Unable and/or unwilling to meet child's needs | |||||
Poor attachment | |||||
Evidence of rejection towards the child | |||||
Lack of interest in child | |||||
Threats/requests to have the child accommodated | |||||
Child perceived as difficult and/or labelled by parent | |||||
Prioritises adult needs over child's | |||||
Inappropriate rigid attitudes towards child | |||||
Partner is not biological parent of child | |||||
New partner -background is unknown | |||||
Parental resistance/limited engagement | |||||
Refuses workers access to child | |||||
Parents masking the reality of the situation | |||||
No shared understanding of concerns | |||||
Child's account minimised/not believed by carer | |||||
Physical illness which impairs parenting ability | |||||
Mental illness which impairs parenting ability | |||||
Substance misuse which impairs parenting ability | |||||
Physical disability which impairs parenting ability | |||||
High stress levels such as poverty, isolation, loss | |||||
Parents' parenting was poor/abusive | |||||
Low self-esteem | |||||
Poor life skills and problem solving abilities | |||||
Poor impulse control | |||||
Difficulty with communication | |||||
Lack of trust towards workers and others | |||||
History of multiple relationships | |||||
Carer continually defers to partner for response | |||||
History of domestic violence | |||||
History of community violence | |||||
History of violence /aggression towards workers | |||||
Parents in conflict over custody or residence | |||||
Inability/unwilling-ness to make use of supports | |||||
Breaches of legal orders/agreement - criminal/civil |
Risk Indicators Particular to the Child's Family and Wider World
(My Wider World)
Generic Indicators - Wider World | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Child 4 | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Family socially isolated | |||||
Absence of social supports/networks | |||||
Problems within extended family | |||||
Illness within extended family | |||||
Conflict within extended family | |||||
Substance misuse within extended family | |||||
Family - frequent changes of address | |||||
Home environment chaotic, unsafe | |||||
Concerns about sleeping arrangements | |||||
Family history of poor engagement with services | |||||
Discriminated within community victim/perpetrator | |||||
Culturally inappropriate behaviours | |||||
Neighbourhood characterised by offending/violence | |||||
Neighbourhood characterised by poverty | |||||
Housing quality poor | |||||
Lack of community services |
What is the information telling me?
Using the Record Sheets practitioners should under each of the risk domains analyse the information gathered asking the key question, "what is this information telling me?".
1. Consider the information gathered and identify the key risk factors for child, parent/carer and wider world. The Record Sheets will highlight the specific areas of concern/risk (your evidence) but you should give an overview of what you consider to be the key issues within the three domains.
2. You then need to form a view as to the level of risk for the child taking account of the interaction between the child, the parent/carer and the child's wider world. What is the information telling you about the level of concern/risk?
Risk Indicators for |
---|
Child 1 |
Child 2 |
Child 3 |
Child 4 |
Parent/Carer |
Family and Wider World |
What is the information telling me about the level of concern/risk? (Consider frequency, duration, severity, single or accumulative in nature - significance of factors in reaching a conclusion about the level of risk.) |
---|
Matrix Related Risk Indicators
A collection of Risk Indicators directly linked to each axis of the Resilience-Vulnerability Matrix which lead practitioners to examine Resilience, Adversity, Vulnerability and Protective Factors. Drawn from research and practice these aim to help highlight potential strength and risk factors within a child/young persons life circumstances. Again, each are directly examined relative to the three dimensions of assessment within the My World Triangle - the child (how I grow and develop), parent/carer (what I need from the people who care for me) and their wider world.
Resilience Indicators
Resilience Risk Indicators Particular to the Child
(How I Grow and Develop)
Risk Indicators - The Child | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Child 4 | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Secure attachment to primary carer | |||||
Positive self-esteem | |||||
Ability to use adults for support and assistance | |||||
Good communication skills | |||||
Ability to deal with change | |||||
Good problem solving skills | |||||
Positive sense of belonging | |||||
Positive sense of own identity |
Resilience Risk Indicators Particular to the Parent/Carer
(What I Need from the People Who Look after Me)
Resilience Indicators - Parent/Carer | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Child 4 | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Stable, nurturing caregiver | |||||
Positive family structures and routines | |||||
Stable family environment | |||||
Parents have good self-esteem | |||||
Consistent quality of care | |||||
Good communication within family | |||||
Affectionate bonds within the family | |||||
Reliable emotional support for child | |||||
Good parental supervision |
Resilience Risk Indicators Particular to the Child's Family
and Wider World (My Wider World)
Resilience Indicators - Wider World | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Child 4 | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Supportive adults outwith the family | |||||
Parents suffering from poor mental health supported | |||||
Good community resources (e.g. childcare) | |||||
Child has cultural connections in community | |||||
Wider family supports (e.g. grandparents) | |||||
Community resources combat racism/exclusion |
What is the information telling me?
Using the Record Sheets practitioners should under each of the risk domains analyse the information gathered asking the key question, "what is this information telling me?".
1. Consider the information gathered and identify the key risk factors for child, parent/carer and wider world. The Record Sheets will highlight the specific areas of concern/risk (your evidence) but you should give an overview of what you consider to be the key issues within the three domains.
2. You then need to form a view as to the level of risk for the child taking account of the interaction between the child, the parent/carer and the child's wider world. What is the information telling you about the level of concern/risk?
Risk Indicators for |
---|
Child 1 |
Child 2 |
Child 3 |
Child 4 |
Parent/Carer |
Family and Wider World |
What is the information telling me about the level of concern/risk? (Consider frequency, duration, severity, single or accumulative in nature - significance of factors in reaching a conclusion about the level of risk.) |
---|
Adversity Risk Indicators
Adversity Risk Indicators Particular to the Child
(How I Grow and Develop)
Adversity Indicators - The Child | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Child 4 | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
No significant or primary attachment figure | |||||
No clear boundaries or routines | |||||
Child presenting with abusive behaviours | |||||
Child's behaviour unstable or unpredictable | |||||
Child displays poor coping strategies | |||||
Victim of abuse/ neglect | |||||
Experience of loss/rejection or bereavement | |||||
Repeated changes of placement | |||||
More than 4 children in the home |
Adversity Risk Indicators Particular to the Parent/Carer
(What I Need from the People Who Look after Me)
Adversity Indicators - Parent/Carer | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Child 4 | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Evidence of unresolved childhood trauma | |||||
Living in recurrent crisis | |||||
History of substance misuse | |||||
Isolated within culture/community | |||||
Longstanding mental health problems | |||||
History of criminal/offending behaviour | |||||
History of violence/conflict |
Adversity Risk Indicators Particular to the Child's Family and Wider World (My Wider World)
Adversity Indicators - Wider World | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Child 4 | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
History of concerns about wider family | |||||
Unable/unwilling to overcome adversity |
What is the information telling me?
Using the Record Sheets practitioners should under each of the risk domains analyse the information gathered asking the key question, "what is this information telling me?".
1. Consider the information gathered and identify the key risk factors for child, parent/carer and wider world. The Record Sheets will highlight the specific areas of concern/risk (your evidence) but you should give an overview of what you consider to be the key issues within the three domains.
2. You then need to form a view as to the level of risk for the child taking account of the interaction between the child, the parent/carer and the child's wider world. What is the information telling you about the level of concern/risk?
Risk Indicators for |
---|
Child 1 |
Child 2 |
Child 3 |
Child 4 |
Parent/Carer |
Family and Wider World |
What is the information telling me about the level of concern/risk? (Consider frequency, duration, severity, single or accumulative in nature - significance of factors in reaching a conclusion about the level of risk.) |
---|
Vulnerability Risk Indicators
Vulnerability Risk Indicators Particular to the Child
(How I Grow and Develop)
Vulnerability Indicators - The Child | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Child 4 | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Unwanted or unplanned pregnancy | |||||
Difficult birth | |||||
Born with substance withdrawal | |||||
Child behaviour problems | |||||
Child born at time of crisis | |||||
Developmental impairment or disabilities | |||||
Very young child | |||||
Evidence of insecure attachments | |||||
Child finds it hard to make and keep friends | |||||
Child previously been abused or neglected | |||||
Child resembles a hated partner or spouse | |||||
Asylum seeking child |
Vulnerability Risk Indicators Particular to the Parent/Carer
(What I Need from the People Who Look after Me)
Vulnerability Indicators - Parent/Carer | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Child 4 | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Parental difficulties (e.g. domestic abuse) | |||||
Poor partner relationships/ multiple partners | |||||
Single parent household | |||||
Young parent under 21 years or immature | |||||
Unrealistic expectations of the child | |||||
History of offending | |||||
Chaotic family situation | |||||
Parent abused as a child | |||||
Asylum seeking |
Vulnerability Risk Indicators Particular to the Child's Family and Wider World (My Wider World)
Vulnerability Indicators - Wider World | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Child 4 | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
No access to community resources | |||||
Subject to racism or other isolating factors | |||||
Poor/unsuitable housing | |||||
Homelessness | |||||
Financial difficulties | |||||
Residing detention centre/secure accommodation | |||||
Family home overcrowded | |||||
Lack of extended family support | |||||
Poor support networks |
What is the information telling me?
Using the Record Sheets practitioners should under each of the risk domains analyse the information gathered asking the key question, "what is this information telling me?".
1. Consider the information gathered and identify the key risk factors for child, parent/carer and wider world. The Record Sheets will highlight the specific areas of concern/risk (your evidence) but you should give an overview of what you consider to be the key issues within the three domains.
2. You then need to form a view as to the level of risk for the child taking account of the interaction between the child, the parent/carer and the child's wider world. What is the information telling you about the level of concern/risk?
Risk Indicators for |
---|
Child 1 |
Child 2 |
Child 3 |
Child 4 |
Parent/Carer |
Family and Wider World |
What is the information telling me about the level of concern/risk? (Consider frequency, duration, severity, single or accumulative in nature - significance of factors in reaching a conclusion about the level of risk.) |
---|
Protective Indicators
Protective Indicators Particular to the Child
(How I Grow and Develop)
Protective Indicators - The Child | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Child 4 | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Child is in good health | |||||
Older child able to keep self safe | |||||
Outgoing personality | |||||
Child demonstrates good self-control | |||||
Bright/intelligent child | |||||
Child has high self-esteem | |||||
Child has positive relationships in their life | |||||
Regular nursery or school attendance | |||||
Involvement in out of school activities | |||||
The child is aware and supports the Child's Plan | |||||
Parents support the Child's Plan |
Protective Indicators Particular to the Parent/Carer
(What I Need from the People Who Look after Me)
Protective Indicators - Parent /Carer | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Child 4 | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Parent has good relationship with child | |||||
Parent has a positive view of the child | |||||
Parents understands the needs of the child | |||||
Consistent caring, responsive to the needs of the child | |||||
Demonstrates effective parenting | |||||
Resilient and a good parental role model | |||||
Demonstrates motivation to change | |||||
Willing to receive help and accepts Responsibility | |||||
Capacity for change - shows insight/initiative | |||||
Actively involved in planning work | |||||
Open to feedback/ advice/difficult conversations | |||||
Good relationship with professionals | |||||
Ability to manage behaviour appropriately | |||||
Relatively few sources of stress | |||||
Strong relationship with own parents/carers | |||||
Mental health problems respond to treatment | |||||
Overcome own childhood abuse | |||||
Positive childhood experiences | |||||
No previous history of abuse |
Protective Indicators Particular to the Child's Family and Wider World (My Wider World)
Protective Indicators - My Wider World | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Child 4 | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Supportive extended family | |||||
Regular, positive contact with extended family | |||||
Ability to access /use appropriate services | |||||
Strong relationship with own parents | |||||
Access to supportive | |||||
Family settled in their home | |||||
Family live in a safe and secure neighbourhood | |||||
Access to resources (health, education etc) | |||||
Sufficient income and good physical living standards | |||||
No previous professional supports | |||||
Shared agency understanding of issues/planning |
What is the information telling me?
Using the Record Sheets practitioners should under each of the risk domains analyse the information gathered asking the key question, "what is this information telling me?".
1. Consider the information gathered and identify the key risk factors for child, parent/carer and wider world. The Record Sheets will highlight the specific areas of concern/risk (your evidence) but you should give an overview of what you consider to be the key issues within the three domains.
2. You then need to form a view as to the level of risk for the child taking account of the interaction between the child, the parent/carer and the child's wider world. What is the information telling you about the level of concern/risk?
Risk Indicators for |
---|
Child 1 |
Child 2 |
Child 3 |
Child 4 |
Parent/Carer |
Family and Wider World |
What is the information telling me about the level of concern/risk? (Consider frequency, duration, severity, single or accumulative in nature - significance of factors in reaching a conclusion about the level of risk.) |
---|
Resistance Related Risk Indicators
A collection of Resistance Related Risk Indicators drawn from research and practice that help highlight potential risk factors within a child/young persons life circumstances relative to the three dimensions of assessment within the My World Triangle - the child (how I grow and develop), parent/carer (what I need from the people who care for me) and their wider world.
Resistance Factors
Resistance Related Risk Indicators Particular to the Child
(How I Grow and Develop)
Resistance Indicators - The Child | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Child 4 | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Scapegoated for disclosing family problems | |||||
Fearful/unwilling to disclose anything further | |||||
Identifies with the perpetrator/strong feelings for abuser | |||||
Finds ways of coping with abuse (dissociates) | |||||
Child normalises damaging home circumstances |
Resistance Related Risk Indicators Particular to the Parent/Carer
(What I Need from the People Who Look after Me)
Resistance Indicators - Parent/Carer | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Child 4 | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Threatening workers (physical/ verbal) | |||||
No recognition of the problems | |||||
Has a different perception of the problems/risks | |||||
Only recognises some professional concerns | |||||
No/limited/tokenistic capacity for change | |||||
Parent/carer over-whelmed with situation | |||||
Gives different information to different workers | |||||
Says right things - not backed by behaviour/actions | |||||
Past negative relationships with professionals | |||||
No/limited aware-ness of impact of own behaviour | |||||
Lacks under-standing of what is expected of them | |||||
Actively disrupts professional plans and actions |
Resistance Related Risk Indicators Particular to the Child's Wider World (My Wider World)
Resistance Indicators - My Wider World | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Child 4 | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Poor family/ community support networks | |||||
Changes service driven not driven by parent/carer | |||||
Professional splits/disagreements | |||||
Cultural issues impact on engagement | |||||
Services not available to tackle the problem |
What is the information telling me?
Using the Record Sheets practitioners should under each of the risk domains analyse the information gathered asking the key question, "what is this information telling me?".
1. Consider the information gathered and identify the key risk factors for child, parent/carer and wider world. The Record Sheets will highlight the specific areas of concern/risk (your evidence) but you should give an overview of what you consider to be the key issues within the three domains.
2. You then need to form a view as to the level of risk for the child taking account of the interaction between the child, the parent/carer and the child's wider world. What is the information telling you about the level of concern/risk?
Risk Indicators for |
---|
Child 1 |
Child 2 |
Child 3 |
Child 4 |
Parent/Carer |
Family and Wider World |
What is the information telling me about the level of concern/risk? (Consider frequency, duration, severity, single or accumulative in nature - significance of factors in reaching a conclusion about the level of risk.) |
---|
Contact
There is a problem
Thanks for your feedback