Partial Business and Regulatory Impact Assessment (Northern North Sea) - Fisheries Management Measures within Scottish Offshore Marine Protected Areas (MPAs)

This assessment is undertaken to estimate the costs, benefits and risks of proposed management measures for sites within Northern North Sea that may impact the public, private or third sector.


Public Sector Costs

The decision to implement fisheries management measures would result in additional costs incurred by the public sector for compliance and enforcement. An estimate for the annual costs associated with compliance and enforcement has been informed by Marine Scotland Compliance.

Table 11 Present value of public sector costs for Option 2 (2022 prices, over 20 years) (£000).
Activity Estimated costs
Increased VMS polling rate 17.8
Increased resources at UKFMC 1,920.6
Total 1,938.4

Compliance costs were estimated for the full 21 sites. Due to vessel traffic and site numbers, it is estimated that 60% of the costs would be assigned to the North North Sea sites assessed in this BRIA.

Option 3: Do nothing

In the absence of the proposed measures a significant amount of Scotland’s offshore marine species and habitats are at risk to potentially damaging fishing activity, existing fisheries measures excepted. Under this option, environmental damage may occur, and therefore site conservation objectives would not be achieved.

Future costs may arise from this through processes outlined under Rationale for Government Intervention.

Cost summary tables

Table 12 outlines the overall estimated costs for each option detailing the GVA impact, loss in value of landings, public sector costs and impacts on employment, as discussed under each option above.

A full breakdown of costs per site is available in Annex B.

Table 12. Cost summary tables for Option 1 and Option 2.
Scenario Option 1 – Zonal management of damaging gears Option 2- Site closure to damaging gears
Direct + indirect GVA impact (£000s) (PV) 1,007.8 – 10,742.6 29,055.4 - 42,863.3
Annual average loss in value on landings (£000s) 103.7 - 1,303.4 3,552.0 - 5,270.3
Public Sector costs (£000s) 5,836.7 1,938.4
Direct + indirect reduction in employment (FTE) 1.3-16.3 44.7-66.3

Contact

Email: marine_biodiversity@gov.scot

Back to top