Reducing emissions from agriculture – the role of new farm technologies

This research identified and evaluated technologies which could offer carbon savings in Scottish agriculture which are not currently in use but could be brought to market within 20 years. A shortlist of technologies were explored in greater detail to identify candidates for accelerated development.


1.0 Introduction and Background

Agriculture represented 16% of Scotland's emissions in 2018[3]. The Scottish Government has committed to reaching net zero emissions by 2045, including a reduction of 75% by 2030. The Scottish Government's Climate Change Plan update[4] requires the equivalent of a 31% reduction in agricultural emissions by 2032 from 2018 levels. Between 1990-2019 Scottish agriculture’s emissions decreased by only 13%.

Recent work on marginal abatement cost curves (Eory et al., 2022) presents a number of areas which, if adopted at scale, would support progress towards the net zero target in 2045. These technologies offer a feasible set of solutions which could be adopted for farming at a range of costs for on-farm adoption. As these effects and costs are reasonably well tested then more certainties can be placed on their potential if adopted by industry. These technologies, studied in the MACC for Scotland are shown in table 1.

Table 1. MACC mitigation measures

Mitigation measure

Abatement

Abatement cost

kt CO2e y-1

£ (t CO2e)-1

Grass-legume mix

52

-1,044

Variable rate nitrogen

19

-628

Current breeding goal in dairy

39

-426

Genomics breeding dairy

58

-446

Genomics breeding beef

7

-432

Health dairy

11

-381

Lower emission breeding goal dairy

32

-339

AD pig poultry

10

-274

Soil compaction

2

-255

Health sheep

39

-244

AD cattle

30

-184

Lower emission breeding goal beef

8

-356

Health beef

25

-2

Slurry acidification dairy

32

-1

Faster finishing beef

66

0

Increasing beef calving rate

29

0

Reducing beef calving interval

4

0

Sexed semen in dairy

71

0

Soil pH

17

17

Slurry acidification beef

42

28

Impermeable slurry cover dairy

10

34

Impermeable slurry cover beef

9

36

Nitrate feed additive beef

119

38

Grain legumes

18

76

Slurry acidification pigs

2

84

Nitrate feed additive dairy

22

84

3NOP dairy

30

85

Cover crops

33

110

Impermeable slurry cover pigs

0

122

Nitrate feed additive sheep

4

196

3NOP beef

51

226

Nitrification inhibitor

18

319

High fat diet beef

13

504

Urease inhibitor

2

518

High fat diet sheep

6

909

High fat diet dairy

1

3,395

Total

931

Source: Eory et al. (2022

These technologies were also further explored with Farmer Led Groups which suggests that future policy has to recognise technologies which are both cost-effective to adopt and attractive for the farmer[5].

Contact

Email: hilary.grant@gov.scot

Back to top