Biometric data retention: review report

Annex D

Bibliography

Ada Lovelace Institute. "The Citizens' Biometrics Council" (2021).

Ada Lovelace Institute. "Countermeasures: the need for new legislation to govern biometric technologies in the UK" (2022).

Age of Criminal Responsibility (Scotland) Act 2019 – "Chapter 4, Part 4".

Amankwaa, Aaron O. "Forensic DNA Retention: Public Perspective Studies in the United Kingdom and Around the World".

Amankwaa, Aaron, and Carole McCartney. "Gaughran Vs the UK and Public Acceptability of Forensic Biometrics Retention".

Amankwaa, Aaron, and Carole McCartney. "The UK National DNA Database: Implementation of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012".

Amankwaa, Aaron, and Carole McCartney. "The effectiveness of the UK national DNA database" (2019).

Amelung, Nina. and Rafaela Granja & Helena Machado "A Brief History of the Evolution of Biometrics and Biometric Database Systems Crossing Borders in EU Law Enforcement".

Bacalu, Filip. "Biometric Facial Recognition Technology, Law Enforcement Algorithmic Automation, and Data-Driven Predictive Policing Systems in Human Rights Protections and Abuses".

Bacalu, Filip. "Digital Policing Tools as Social Control Technologies: Data-Driven Predictive Algorithms, Automated Facial Recognition Surveillance, and Law Enforcement Biometrics".

College of Policing "Management of Police Information – Review, Retention and Disposal" (Updated 2023).

Commissioner for the Retention and Use of Biometric Material. "Annual Report." (2018).

Commissioner for the Retention and Use of Biometric Material. "Annual Report 2019" (2020).

Commissioner for the Retention and Use of Biometric Material. "Annual Report 2020" (2021).

Commissioner for the Retention and Use of Biometric Material. "Annual Report 2021-22" (2023).

Commissioner for the Retention and Use of Biometric Material. "Annual Report 2022-23" (2024).

Costa, Susana "Travelling to Prüm –euphoria and dysphoria regarding the use of DNA data between and beyond borders".

Council of Europe. "Case of S. and Marper v. The United Kingdom 30562/04 ECHR 1581" (2008).

Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 2003 – "Section 56".

Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 – "Part 2 - Sections 18-19C".

Data Protection Act 2018. "Part 3, Chapter 2".

"EU reverses Bulgarian life sentence for biometric criminal records" - Biometricupdate.com.

European Court of Human Rights. "Gaughran v. the United Kingdom - 45245/15." (2020).

Fraser, J. "Acquisition and retention of DNA and fingerprint data in Scotland" (2008).

Furberg, Robert D., et al. "Biometrics and Policing: A Protocol for Multichannel Sensor Data Collection and Exploratory Analysis of Contextualized Psychophysiological Response during Law Enforcement Operations".

Grünenberg, Kristina et al "IDentities and Identity: Biometric Technologies, Borders and Migration".

Home Office, Consultation – "Keeping the right people on the DNA database – Science and Public Protection" (2009) Pease, Ken. Jill Dando Institute. DNA Retention after S & Marper (2009).

Home Office, Guidance - The national process for record deletion in respect of records held on the PNC, the National DNA Database (NDNAD) and the National Fingerprints Database (IDENT1)" (updated 2023).

Home Office. "Review of the Use and Retention of Custody Images" (2017).

Home Office. "Biometrics Strategy, Better public services Maintaining public trust." (2018).

House of Commons Science and Technology Committee. "Current and future uses of biometric data and technologies" (2015).

House of Commons Science and Technology Committee. "The work of the Biometrics Commissioner and the Forensic Science Regulator"(2019).

Jacobsen, Katja L. "Biometric Data Flows and Unintended Consequences of Counterterrorism."

Kindt, E. J. "Having Yes, using no? about the New Legal Regime for Biometric Data".

Kindt, E "First Attempt at Regulating Biometric Data in the European Union".

"LQDN fights to protect French citizens from biometric mass surveillance" – erdi.org.

Machado, Helena, and Susana Silva. "What Influences Public Views on Forensic DNA Testing in the Criminal Field? A Scoping Review of Quantitative Evidence".

Maclean, Holly, and Swann, Julia. Children and Young People's Centre for Justice (CYCJ) "Thematic Review of Biometric Data – Children and Young People's

Perspectives" (2023).

Marshall, Daniel, and Thomas, Terry. "Privacy and Criminal Justice - Police (3): Data Collection and Retention" (2017).

Montag, Luca et al "The Rise and Rise of Biometric Mass Surveillance in the EU - A Legal Analysis of Biometric Mass Surveillance Practices in Germany, the Netherlands, and Poland".

Northern Ireland Executive – Department of Justice. "A consultation on proposals to amend the legislation governing the retention of DNA and fingerprints in Northern Ireland" (2020).

Northern Ireland Executive – Department of Justice. "A consultation on proposals to amend the legislation governing the retention of DNA and fingerprints in Northern Ireland – Summary of Responses" (2021).

Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Act 2023.

Olena Kostiuchenko et al "The Impact of DNA Databases on the Investigation of Crimes".

Police Scotland. Recording, Weeding and Retention of Information on Criminal History System (CHS) Guidance" (2018).

Police Scotland. "Standard Operating Procedure – DNA Sampling and Retention". (updated 2019).

Police Scotland. "Standard Operating Procedure – Fingerprints". (updated 2019).

Police Scotland. "Standard Operating Procedure – Record Retention". (updated 2023).

Primorac, Damir, and Andrej Božinovski. "Correcting Miscarriages of Justice in Croatia: Accession and Time-Limited Retention of DNA Profiles in the Jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights."

Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 – "Part 1 - Regulation of Biometric Data".

Reed, Kristiina and Court, Synderdome Denise. "A comparative audit of legislative frameworks within the European Union for the collection, retention and use of forensic DNA profiles" (2014) (Updated 2016).

Richmond, McGregor Karen. "Human Rights Compatibility of Biometric Data

Retention on Shared UK Databases" (2021).

Ryder KC, Matthew. Ada Lovelace Institute. "Independent legal review of the governance of biometric data in England and Wales" (2022).

Scottish Biometrics Commissioner Act 2020.

Scottish Biometrics Commissioner. "Annual Report and Accounts 2021-22" (2022).

Scottish Biometrics Commissioner and Scotcen Social Research. "Public Attitudes to Police Use of Biometric Data"(2022).

Scottish Biometrics Commissioner. Code of Practice on the acquisition, retention, use and destruction of biometric data for criminal justice and police purposes in Scotland" (2022).

Scottish Biometrics Commissioner and Scottish Police Authority. "Joint Assurance Review of the acquisition of biometric data from children arrested in Scotland" (2023).

Scottish Biometrics Commissioner and Scottish Police Authority. "Joint Assurance Review of the acquisition of biometric data from vulnerable persons in police custody requiring the support of an Appropriate Adult under The Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 2016 (Support for Vulnerable Persons) Regulations 2019" (2023).

Scottish Biometrics Commissioner. "Annual Report 2022-23" (2023).

Scottish Biometrics Commissioner. "Annual Compliance Assessments for Statutory Code of Practice 2023/24 – Police Scotland" (2024).

Scottish Biometrics Commissioner. "Annual Compliance Assessments for Statutory Code of Practice 2023/24 – Scottish Police Authority" (2024).

Scottish Biometrics Commissioner. "Annual Compliance Assessments for Statutory Code of Practice 2023/24 – Police Investigations and Review Commissioner" (2024).

Scottish Biometrics Commissioner. "Assurance Review of the acquisition, use and retention of images and photographs for criminal justice and police purposes" (2024).

Scottish Government. "Report of the Independent Advisory Group on Biometric Data in Scotland" (March 2018).

Scottish Government. "Reconviction Rates in Scotland: 2018-19 Offender Cohort" (2021).

Scottish Police Authority. "Home Office Biometrics Programme: Implications and future options for biometric data and biometric policing databases in Scotland" (2020).

Scottish Police Authority. "Scottish DNA Database Statistics 2023/2024" (last accessed April 2024).

Sepúlveda Carmona, Magdalena. "Biometric Technology and Beneficiary Rights in Social Protection Programmes".

Shopo, Md et al "Biometric Systems De-Identification: Current Advancements and Future Directions".

Smith, Marcus and Seumas Miller. "The Ethical Application of Biometric Facial Recognition Technology".

Stockwell, Sam, Hughes, Megan, Ashurst, Carolyn and Ní Loideáin, Nóra. "The Future of Biometric Technology for Policing and Law Enforcement - Informing UK Regulation" (2024).

Teodorović, Smilja, et al. "Attitudes regarding the National Forensic DNA Database: Survey Data from the General Public, Prison Inmates and Prosecutors' Offices in the Republic of Serbia".

Tooley, Jason. "The Future of Biometrics in Policing Worldwide".

Tuazon, Oliver M. "Universal Forensic DNA Databases: Acceptable Or Illegal Under the European Court of Human Rights Regime?".

University of Kent. "Criminal Justice Notes - Expert insights into significant, contemporary developments in criminal law, policing and criminal procedure in the UK, Ireland and the EU - Police retention and use of biometric data" (2019).

Wienroth, Matthias, and Nina Amelung. "'Crisis', Control and Circulation: Biometric Surveillance in the Policing of the 'Crimmigrant Other".

Wong, Kelly A. "The Face-Id Revolution: The Balance between Pro-Market and Pro-Consumer Biometric Privacy Regulation".