Deer (Scotland) Act 1996 - proposed amendments: consultation analysis

British Association for Shooting and Conservation Response

Proposal 1.

Permitting the use of light intensifying, heat sensitive or other special sighting devices to shoot deer at night.

BASC supports this proposal, providing it is not purely restricted to thermal imaging sights. We feel that modern digital night vision scopes and IR illuminators are more than fit for purpose for the humane shooting of deer. We note the concerns raised over the use of some infra-red night vision devices and that “these were not fit for purpose for deer culling at night”. (NatureScot Report 1311.) However, the infra-red equipment tested was older and less efficient than what is currently available.

While there is some concern over the use of these scopes at night, we recognise that all who are licensed to shoot at night are on the Fit and Competent register and therefore should be experienced.

We also suggest that the wording of the amended legislation is clear and would permit the use of these sighting devices (scopes) for routine deer management during the day as well as at during licensed shooting at night. Currently, sighting devices with the capability of thermal imaging and image intensifying cannot be used during the day, even if that specific function of the scope is switched off. This would allow rifles fitted with such scopes to be used during the day.

BASC is also in favour of this as it would align legislation with that of England and Wales and would reduce confusion and complexities for those managing deer across Great Britain.

We are aware that Wild Deer Best Practice Guidance on the use of such devices is in preparation, and we suggest that this is published before the legislative changes are made.

Proposal 2.

Amending the minimum bullet weight so as to make non-lead ammunition more accessible.

BASC supports this decision as it will help to alleviate some of the most prevalent and common grievances that members have with the transition to lead-free ammunition (namely that the

.243 and similar calibres would otherwise struggle to meet legal minimums).

BASC’s recommendations to the UK REACH consultation stated that small calibres (below 6.5mm) needed a lot longer transitional period than larger calibres, given the issues of heavier bullet weights (100 grain) in these calibres not stabilising. Whilst we are confident that this recommendation has been listened to, the proposed legislative change by Scottish Government would be a welcomed one, allowing stalkers that use a .243 or similar to make the transition to lead-free ammunition without the need for getting a new rifle or barrel. Many stalkers are already required to use lead-free ammunition, be it through lease conditions or AGHE requirement. This proposal would ensure that stalkers in these situations can continue to manage deer populations and supply venison into the food chain.

There is some concern surrounding the possible use of 80 grain bullets to cull large deer (red, fallow and sika) at night, when the follow-up and despatch of a wounded deer is harder than during the day. Consideration could be given to either condition night shooting licenses to require the use of bullet weights of 100 grains or more, or require the use of a calibre of 6.5mm or greater. This could also be incorporated into the Night Shooting Code of Practice.

Proposal 3

Removal of closed seasons for male deer.

BASC disagrees with this proposal as we feel that it is not necessary nor that it will help reduce population levels. Wild Deer Best Practice states that “a reduction cull must focus on the females” and we suggest that instead of removing the male deer close season an incentive is given to control more female deer, where appropriate.

The General Authorisation under Section 5 6 (a) of the Deer (Scotland) Act 1996 already allows the shooting of male deer in the close season to prevent damage to crops, pasture, enclosed woodland etc. There is no need for an owner or occupier to apply for an individual authorisation, apart from in limited exceptions. We therefore feel that the removal of the close season will have no real impact upon the numbers of male deer shot in Scotland since the General Authorisation allows the year-round culling of male deer when they are causing problems.

In addition, no close season for male deer could exacerbate the problem of over-population (where it exists) as more male deer could be shot through the winter months when deer managers should be concentrating on culling females.

With the current political climate around “trophy” hunting, there could well be a negative response from the public regarding this change. It is not hard to imagine how those with an anti-stalking agenda could use this to claim that the stalking industry wanted more time/opportunity to hunt trophies.